The first cool morning in Wilmington always catches me in the garden with wet hands and nothing warm on my arms. I am out there before seven with the zinnias, and by the time I come in my shoulders are stiff from the damp. For years I solved that with a heavy knit that had me sweating by nine, and before that with a zip-up fleece that pilled under the arms before Thanksgiving.
Last spring I ordered the PRETTYGARDEN open front oversized cardigan for a plain reason. I wanted something I could throw on over whatever I was already wearing, that would not fight me at the shoulders, and that I would not have to think about again until lunch. It arrived folded flat, and I wore it out to the beds the next morning with my coffee still in my hand.
The knit is 72 percent polyester, 24 percent acrylic and 4 percent elastane. What that means at the elbow and the wrist is a fabric with a little spring in it, soft against the skin rather than scratchy, which matters more to me at sixty-seven than any label does. It is a crew neck, long sleeve, open front, with the fit listed as regular and a loose cut through the body.
There is no closure to fuss with, and that is the whole point. No zip to line up, no buttons to hunt for with garden hands. I slide the PRETTYGARDEN cardigan on and it stays where I put it. The loose fit means it hangs instead of clinging, and the open front means I can wear it over a t-shirt in April and over a long sleeve in November.
I should be honest about what came before it. The fleece jacket was warm and ugly by the second winter, with little balls of fuzz along the cuffs. The zip cardigan I bought the year before grabbed at the shoulder seams every time I reached for a high branch. Neither of them was wrong, exactly. They just did not survive the way I use clothes, which is hard and daily and mostly outdoors.
It is listed for fall, spring and winter, and I think that is fair. This is not a coat. On a raw January morning I want something heavier. But from late March through May, and again from September until the real cold sets in, it is the layer I reach for without thinking.
Eleven washes on cold, dried on low, and the elbows have not gone thin. That is the test I actually care about.
The layer I put on before I put the kettle on
Open front, loose knit, nothing to zip or button at six in the morning. It has gone from the garden beds to the grocery store without one person asking why I was dressed for yard work.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →The grocery run is where I made up my mind. I had been in the beds all morning and I went straight to the store with dirt under my nails and the PRETTYGARDEN cardigan over my old shirt. Nobody looked at me twice. That sounds like a small thing. It is not. Half my closet is clothes that only work in one room of the house.
The sleeves are long and they stay long. I push them up when I am working and they hold the roll instead of sliding back down my forearm every thirty seconds. Small detail, but if you have ever wrestled a sleeve back up with wet hands, you know it is the difference between a sweater you wear and one that hangs in the closet.
On Saturdays Walt and I walk the beach, and the wind off the water cuts through most everything. The cardigan is fine on those walks as long as I keep moving. It does not block wind the way a jacket does, so I keep a proper jacket in the car for the days the wind turns. That is not a complaint. It is just the truth about a knit.
Laundry is where I judge everything I own. I have washed this one on cold and dried it on low eleven times now, and it has kept its shape through all of them. No sagging at the neck, no thin patch at the elbows. My one real gripe is that there are no pockets. I like a pocket for a tissue and a grocery list, and I have thought about sewing one in and decided against ruining a good thing.
Evenings it ends up over my shoulders on the couch with a book, which is where it lives from about eight o'clock on. Walt has started calling it the reading sweater, which tells you most of what you need to know about how it looks by then.
What I'd Tell You If We Were Sitting at My Kitchen Table
I would tell you to buy it for the season you are actually in, not the one in the catalog photographs. I would tell you to wash it cold and dry it low, because that is what I have done and it has held. I would tell you there are no pockets, and I miss them. I would tell you the fit runs generous, so if you are between sizes and you want it close to the body, go down one. And I would tell you the thing I tell everybody our age about clothes: buy the piece you can put on without thinking, because that is the piece you will actually wear. Everything else is decoration.
One layer that earns its hook by the door
It has been to the garden, the store and the beach, and it still looks like something I would answer the door in. For a plain open front knit, that is enough.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →